Nov 172026

Summary
The Milburn Report is about why young people are not in education or training.
Milburn wants the Government to take money off disabled people.
Disabled People Against Cuts (DPAC) has written this guide about why Milburn is wrong.
General Points
- These are proposals that seek to fund employment support for mainly non-Disabled young people by removing essential benefits from Disabled young people with the highest levels of need and their families.
- The majority of the public want a social security system that is targeted at those most in need. These proposals are at odds with that, removing essential support from Disabled young people in violation of their human rights while at the same time investing in wider employment support for all young people.
- Acceptance of the Milburn recommendations within the Timms review makes a mockery of the Timms co-production panel. Incorporation of co-production within the Timms review was given as a concession to persuade Labour MPs to vote with the government on 1 July. It is no surprise to Deaf and Disabled people and our organisations that the Government has found a route to sidelining that co-production input shortly before publication of its findings.
- It needs to be restated yet again that welfare costs are not spiralling and there is no urgency about tackling the disability benefits bill. There are multiple factors influencing the increase in applications for PIP, all of which highlight the needlessness of panicking. Welfare spending as a proportion of GDP has remained broadly stable for the past decade and is not set to rise for another five.
Young people, disability and NEET status
- Only 28% of NEETs in this age group claim disability benefits with 44% not claiming any benefits at all. Of this 28%, roughly 70% (seven in ten) of young people aged 16 to 24 receiving PIP in England and Wales previously received child DLA and transitioned via a reassessment.
- The Government is worried about rising numbers of young people Not In Education, Employment or Training. There are again multiple factors behind this, not least the impacts of Covid and austerity measures.
- The Government is choosing to wrongly conflate increased applications for disability benefits with rising numbers of young people who are NEET in order to scapegoat Disabled young people and make Disabled people pay for the failure of previous Government policies.
- What is known so far about the Milburn proposals omits further investment in Access to Work. Applicants for AtW are increasingly denied support on the basis that their needs should be covered by their PIP. For young people without PIP, and without additional investment as part of these proposals, it is unclear how these support needs will be met.
Poverty
- Receiving Universal Credit Health and/or Personal Independence Payment (PIP) currently keeps 120,000 young people out of poverty.
- Disability-related poverty already now accounts for nearly half of all poverty in the UK: around 48% to 50% of all people in poverty in the UK either have a disability themselves or live with someone who does.
- A recent figure being used to justify cuts to PIP is highly questionable: the Resolution Foundation recently cited survey findings of 1 in 6 PIP recipients reporting no specifically disability-related expenditure, however DRE is notoriously difficult to identify without some form of explanation. RF have so far ignored requests to share their survey questions.
- Reassurances that those most in need will be protected do not add up. It is unlikely that a single replacement benefit will cover the same as separate UC health and PIP payments.
- At the moment we have separate disability unemployment and disability costs benefits and even then, there are additional costs both from long-term unemployment and disability-related that are not covered anywhere, leading to high levels of disability poverty and widening disability inequality.
- Scope estimates that Disabled households in the UK need an average of £1,095 extra per month (£13,140 a year) to have the same standard of living as non-disabled households, rising to £1,224 per month by 2029 to 2030 financial year.
- Disabled young people who are neurodivergent or who live with overwhelming psychological and/or emotional distress also face these additional costs as much as – sometimes more than – people with physical impairments. Social care support policies often effectively exclude them from eligibility and appropriate therapy available on the NHS is frequently only available after symptoms have already escalated an become entrenched or not at all.
- Workplaces often find it easier to employ people with physical impairments than people with social, communication and behavioural support needs.
- Plans for local funds for specific items of equipment will leave unmet the majority of support and therapeutic needs that a new single benefit is unable to cover, taking us back decades and effectively pushing Disabled people even further to the margins of society.
- We know from experiences with the closure of the ILF how central funding streams are able to ensure less burdensome and much more effective support for Disabled people than overly bureaucratic and less efficient local authorities which have considerably greater overheads.
- Both the UC health component and PIP are insufficiently generous and less Disabled people get it than need it. Further tightening of eligibility will have devastating impacts on our communities during a cost of living crisis including rising levels of debt, neglect, mental distress, self-harm, suicide, substance dependency and pressures on the criminal justice system.
- We are deeply concerned about the impact of these proposals in sending Disabled young people on direct pathways to prison and/or substance dependency from which they never escape.
Wider impacts on Disabled young people
- 260,000 young people currently receive Universal Credit Health without mandatory requirements to move toward work, education, or training. Milburn’s proposals recommend replacing this with an alternative system with tighter eligibility.
- Any tightening of eligibility that exposes more Disabled young people to conditionality and sanctions places them at risk of losing income unfairly when they are unable to meet job search requirements for disability related reasons.
- PIP already plugs gaps left by Access to Work and social care services. These gaps need to be filled before PIP can be taken away.
- Disabled young people with high needs generally transition into adulthood later and the move from children’s to adult support services is already described as a cliff edge that is extremely difficult for families to navigate. Adding removal of essential disability-related income into this period of their lives is going to create unimaginable strain on families and set up Disabled young people for even poorer life outcomes.
- Disabled young people and their families who lose their Motability vehicles as a result of these cuts will be badly impacted. It will also make it more difficult for Disabled young people to participate in education, employment or training
- There is a danger that these proposals could create a bias for segregated education as parents look for more ways to evidence high level needs in order to be more certain of their child receiving a disability top up to standard UC once they reach 16.
- We are concerned about young people carrying trauma being pushed into employment instead of focusing on therapeutic programmes. Addressing trauma earlier in life can ensure far better life outcomes and reduced long-term dependency on public services. Experiences with unsuitable employment in place of therapy can conversely have very adverse impacts on long-term life chances.
- The impact on care leavers without family to help with unmet needs due to loss of income is a particular worry.
Negative impacts on the wider economy
- Increased disability poverty will put further strain on already over-stretched public services. The Disability Policy Centre calculates that every £1 cut from disability benefits increases cost pressures on public services by £1.50.
- Poverty has a high public overall cost. Estimates place the broader cost of poverty to UK public services and the economy at around £78 billion per year (about £1 in every £5 spent on public services).
- Local authorities will also lose out financially from loss of income from social care charging (because most LA policies now take income from DLA/PIP into account when assessing financial contributions).
Long-term direction
- Overhauling the disability benefit system in this way is going to require significant investment at a time when the Government should be fixing broken services in the public interest. They would not spend the amount required to do this unless the long-term plan is for this to apply to all Disabled benefit claimants.
- If the Government is allowed to create such a two tier tax system it is unlikely the younger generation of Disabled people will ever get access to the levels of financial support received by existing claimants – we expect the new system to roll out with them until it entirely replaces what exists now.
- This current attack on disability benefits has been accompanied by continuing attacks on Disabled people who are neurodivergent and who live with trauma and overwhelming mental distress. These proposals are clearly part of a co-ordinated attempt to demonise Disabled people as justification for overhauling our disability benefit system in a way that excludes certain groups of Disabled people and without other available support to fill the gaps. The consequences will be terrible at an individual level and will be felt across society and the economy.
Funding for youth employment support
- Government rhetoric highlights a “moral” need for more young people to be in either education, employment or training. We would cite a “moral” issue with cutting essential funds from Disabled young people to cover the costs of wider youth employment.
- As newly released figures from the Fair Tax Foundation showing the widening $300bn global tax gap of the Silicon Six demonstrate, there is wealth available. Across the wider digital economy, the shortfall from unpaid tax is likely to be above £5 billion a year.
- Plans to bring forward the Jobs Guarantee scheme from after 18 months of unemployment to 12 months and reach 90,000 young people will increase Government funding of free labour for big companies such as Lidl GB and Boots UK, who increased their most recent annual pre-tax profits by £48.7 million and £68 million respectively.