Aug 112012

David Cameron should read out the names each Wednesday at Prime Minister’s questions of those who have died after the Government stripped them of sickness and disability benefits an MP has said. Denis MacShane, Labour MP for Rotherham, in a speech last weekend (Saturday 4 August) accused David Cameron and Nick Clegg of launching launched a ‘vindictive, vicious campaign to strip people with disabilities of their fundamental rights’.

The MP was speaking at a Community union conference held at Wortley Hall, South Yorkshire . He said :

“We judge a society not by how well it pays its bankers or how many gold medals are won but how well it treats the weak and vulnerable.

“Between January and August last year on average 32 people died every week who the Government said were fit to work. One man Stephen Hill died of a heart attack after the Department of Work and Pensions said he was fit to work and he was denied sickness benefits.

“David Cameron should read out each Wednesday the names of those who have been sacrificed to meet his targets for increasing poverty and misery among the weakest in society while he rewards his millionaire mates with tax-cuts worth £40,000 a year.

“The Government has handed over to a private medical constractor Atos, the task of carrying out medical tests to judge eligibility for these new benefits. Appeals against incorrect decisions by Atos are costing £50m a year, with tribunals having to sit on Saturdays and increase staff by 30% to deal with the backlog. Appeals find in favour of the claimant in at least 30% of cases though some experts reckon 9 out of ten appeals would be won if the victim was helped by an expert welfare adviser.

“The most terrifying letter in Britain today is the brown envelope from the DWP instructing a sick or disabled person that they must submit themselves to this firm making £100 million a year by carrying out these tests.

“Charities report that up to half a million disabled people of working age could lose their benefits when the tests are further tightened up next year.

“Yesterday Steve Ford, chief executive of Parkinson’s UK,  said ‘Assessments carried out by Atos have led to many people being forced to appeal against decisions that are plainly wrong. How can someone with Parkinson’s – a progressive neurological condition – have an assessment report that implies they will be ready for work again in six, 12 or 18 months?’

“Labour MPs and our excellent Shadow Minister Anne McGuire have been constantly attacking the Government on this. Before May 2010 Lib Dems would also have stood up for disabled people. Not any longer. The record of LibDems MPs and Minister in acting as cover for this Tory attack on the weak and vulnerable is a disgrace.

“But it is part of a wider attack on working people and those who are not millionaires sitting in the Cabinet.

“We have seen this with the outrageous decision to close down Remploy factories. In 2007, Chris Grayling the Tory MP, now DWP minister, said  ‘Let me assure Remploy and its employees that the next conservative government will continue the process of identifying additional potential procurement opportunities for them and the public sector workforce.’

“We know those words to be a lie. Remploy factories have been closed down and one of the proudest achievements of the post-war Labour government, setting up factories  for the disabled, are now being destroyed. The Remploy workers and their unions are right to protect and strike though I doubt if it will have any impact on this hard-hearted government.

“ Anti-union attack dogs are on the rise everywhere. There is a braying Toryism that hates trade unions and like a child pulling bits off a daddy longlegs Tory MPs seek every opportunity to bash, trash and lash unions. Their main objective is to force a renunciation of the European Union’s social rules.

“The Tory onslaught on social Europe is an ideological and cultural attempt by Thatcher’s and Tebbit’s children and grandchildren to harness the anti-EU feeling in the nation against trade union rights in general.

“It is almost as if the end of communism which the Thatcher-Reagan Tories claim as their great victory is incomplete unless unions are also eliminated from their world. There is a constant grind of anti-union laws and policies. Access to industrial tribunals are made more difficult; backbench bills are introduced to deny shop stewards time off to carry out union duties; modest British financial support for the International Labour Organisation is axed; every time workers vote in a secret ballot to stop work there is a hue and cry about banning or limiting strikes.

“Long standing national pay structures are threatened by proposals for regional pay as if an army Colonel at Catterick in Yorkshire should be paid less than an army Colonel in Aldershot in Surrey.

“From a right-wing ideological point of view there might be some justification for this if the nation was being put back on the path of growth and job creation.

“As we know this is not the case. George Osborne is making a new film ‘Honey, I shrunk the Economy.’ We have the longest recession since the 1930s. Manufacturing output has hit an all-time low. Housing investment has been cut from £2.4 billion in 2010 to under £800 million today. We can win all the gold medals the Olympics can offer but unless we invest in our own nation, in our own people, in all of our regions, and in people like those with disabilities who need a helping hand not a slapdown then our nation will get weaker and weaker.

“The poet Oliver Goldsmith wrote

 Ill fares the land, to gathering ills a prey

 Where wealth accumulates and men decay

“Britain’s wealth is being accumulated by the undeserving rich while the disabled are expected to decay as their life chances are removed from them by Tory ministers and their LibDem helpers.

“It is still 3 years to go to the next Government. And have no illusions that despite negative opinion polls as the Fabian Society recently reported there is no support for higher taxation amongst rank and file Labour supporters.

“Labour needs to build a new 21 st century coalition of support that includes unions like my  good friends in Community to whom I pledge my commitment and support but goes out to the young, to women, to graduates with and without work and speaks for all the nation not any single group within it.

“It is very hard after voters have lost confidence in a party after a long period of power to win that confidence and trust back again. The Tories have all the off-shore press on their side and on most issues the BBC and Sky reflect the interests of the better-off in Britain and the London dislike of social Europe.

“So the challenge is bigger than at any time in Labour’s history. In 1945 it had been 16 years since Labour won power and the country was changed by the egalitarian sacrifices made necessary by war. In 1997, it had been 18 years since Labour held office and the nation was ready for change and new leadership. It is only two years and a bit since we were defeated and although the nation is saying no Cameron it needs more persuasion to say yes again to Labour.

“That is a political challenge we must rise to. The party and its MPs are more united than ever before in period of opposition like the 1980s or the 1950s. Ed Miliband is making a bigger and bigger impression in the Commons. We have a brilliant intake of new MPs who are the smartest political generation in Labour history.

“But now we need to reach out beyond our comfort zone of Tory bashing. That is the challenge and I am sure with Community’s support we can start pedalling hard to win for Britain.”

Rt Hon Dr Denis MacShane | Member of Parliament for Rotherham House of Commons   | London SW1A 0AA    email: | telephone: 0 20 7219 4060


[suffusion-the-author display='description']

  4 Responses to “MacShane Says Cameron Should Read Out Names of Disabled Who Die After Being Rejected for Help by Private Contractors Hired to Slash Disability Numbers”

  1. Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wished to mention that I’ve really enjoyed surfing around your blog posts. In any case I will be subscribing for your feed and I’m hoping you write once more soon!

  2. I agree with everything the first 2 posters said, and note that McShane gave himself a let-out clause with ” there’s no appetite amongst Labour supporters for tax increases “, but all the same it’s slightly heartening to see a prominent Labour figure, even a reactionary war-criminal like McShane, stand up for the sick and disabled so forcibly.

    Compare McShane’s statement (and the recent tv documentaries and Mirror and Mail(?) articles) with this appalling piece from the Socialist Worker – the weekly of the Socialist Workers Party, biggest ‘socialist’ organisation to the left of Labour, once a mainstay of the anti-war movement ( but they’re showing their true colours there now too – as many have noted they’re neither socialists nor workers, but this isn’t the place to get into that):

    OK, maybe the writer was just some young undergraduate on a first assignment, not properly clued up, but this might show how much they care: ” Last year 32 people died while challenging Atos rulings that they were fit for work.”

  3. The WCA was begun by champagne socialists under B-liar and will no doubt continue under Milliband who appears to be just another red toraidhe.

    What I would love to see is everyone who’s going to even bother to vote when the coalition falls apart, voting for anyone they like as long as the candidate is not standing for one of the so-called “Big 3.” Let’s get a bunch of Independents, Greens and other minority parties into Wasteminster and see if THEY will work on behalf of the people, rather than to line their own pockets like the present lot.

    And it’s about time the Met Police put their corruption aside and prosecuted Grayskull and Drunken Stiff for misconduct in public office!

  4. We cannot forget that New Labour was involved in Work Capability Assessments and incapacity benefit reform and Ed Miliband even visited Atos to thank them for their sponsorship of the Paralympics. Labour continues to justify its past by claiming that the benefit system needed reform in order to address “generations of worklessness” when we know that IB fraud was only 0.4% and the reforms have led to thousands of genuine disabled claimants being pushed to death and despair. The failure to acknowledge the fundamentally pernicious nature of the bio-psychosocial model and the injustice in giving public finance over to private companies to profit from pushing disabled people off benefits does not make disabled people feel that we would be safe under a future Labour government.

 Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>



For security, use of Google's reCAPTCHA service is required which is subject to the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.

I agree to these terms.